Negative Inquisitiveness and Alternatives-Based Negation
نویسندگان
چکیده
We propose some fundamental requirements for the treatment of negative particles, positive/negative polar questions, and negative propositions, as they occur in dialogue with questions. We offer a view of negation that combines aspects of alternative semantics, intuitionist negation, and situation semantics. We formalize the account in TTR (a version of type theory with records) [6, 8]. Central to our claim is that negative and positive propositions should be distinguished and that in order to do this they should be defined in terms of types rather than possible worlds. This is in contrast to [10] where negative propositions are identified in terms of the syntactic or morphological properties of the sentences which introduce them.
منابع مشابه
An Ordered Choice Logic Programming Front-End for Answer Set Solvers
Ordered Choice Logic Programming (OCLP) allows for preferencebased decision-making with multiple alternatives without the burden of any form of negation. This complete absence of negation does not weaken the language as both forms (classical and as-failure) can be intuitively simulated in the language. The semantics of the language is based on the preference between alternatives, yielding both ...
متن کاملOn the Role of Negation in Choice Logic Programs
We introduce choice logic programs as negation-free datalog programs that allow rules to have exclusive-only (possibly empty) disjunctions in the head. Such programs naturally model decision problems where, depending on a context, agents must make a decision, i.e. an exclusive choice out of several alternatives. It is shown that such a choice mechanism is in a sense equivalent with negation as ...
متن کاملThere Is No Logical Negation Here, But There Are Alternatives: Modeling Conversational Negation with Distributional Semantics
Logical negation is a challenge for distributional semantics, because predicates and their negations tend to occur in very similar contexts, and consequently their distributional vectors are very similar. Indeed, it is not even clear what properties a “negated” distributional vector should possess. However, when linguistic negation is considered in its actual discourse usage, it often performs ...
متن کاملImplementing Ordered Choice Logic Programming using Answer Set Solvers
Ordered Choice Logic Programming (OCLP) allows for dynamic preference-based decision-making with multiple alternatives without the need for any form of negation. This complete absence of negation does not weaken the language as both forms (classical and as-failure) can be intuitively simulated in the language and eliminated using a simple pre-processor, making it also an easy language for users...
متن کاملAcquisition of Negation and Quantification: Insights From Adult Production and Comprehension.
Inspired by adult models of language production and comprehension, we investigate whether children's nonadult interpretation of ambiguous negative quantified sentences reflects their sensitivity to distributional patterns of language use. Studies 1 and 2 show that ambiguous negative quantified sentences of the sort typically used in acquisition studies are strongly avoided in adult production a...
متن کامل